General info | Administration | Departments | Libraries | Journals | Folklore Database | Links |
Objects, Practices, Approaches
|
Dr. Philip Tagg | High and Low, Cool and Uncool:
aesthetic and historical falsifications about music in Europe |
Kirsten Kearney | Playing Monopoly with the Academics |
Dr. Franz Krieger | One more Grammy for Whitney
Houston:
annotations to musical roots and musical identity in the era of globalization |
Dr. John K.Novak | The Depiction of Hope in Three Christian Popular Songs |
Dr. Rosemary Statelova | Romany participation in the production of local popmusic in Bulgaria today: the ethomusicological approach |
Dr. Lubomir Kavaldjiev | The Third Wave in Popular
Music
(four cognitive models observed in the musical culture development) |
Dr. Yetkin Ozer | Modern Sounds and Traditional
Images:
a video analysis and new trends in Turkish folk music |
David Lloyd | Mercury Models:
Distortion of Language and Identity in New Heavy Metal |
Dr. Ulrich Dieter Einbrodt | The Internet Musician. From
Trackers, Sequencers, Software-Synthesizers,
Virtual Sessions and MP3 Files: Changes in music production and distribution |
Yosef Goldenberg | Recordings of Hebrew Folk Songs in Israel |
Dr. Feza Tansug | Cross-Border Flow of Popular
Culture: Redefining Cultural
Boundaries and Traditions in Bulgaria and Turkey |
Dr. Claire Levy | Playing on Repetitive:
Creativity in Popular Music/Culture |
Barnard Turner | America's Band [again]':
the mid-seventies Beach Boys and pop music as repositioning |
ABSTRACTS
Dr.
Philip Tagg
Institute of Popular Music,
Liverpool, UK
High and Low, Cool and Uncool:
aesthetic and historical falsifications about music in Europe
The intellectual and musical canons of popular music studies
often
seem to function as the reverse of the canons associated
with
conventional approaches to the European art music tradition.
If
the latter did not exist, popular music studies would
in this
sense be unnecessary and, conversely, if no identifiable
aesthetics or practices existed within the popular sphere,
the
conventional study of 'classical' music would have lost
its own
raison d'etre. In short, each sphere of musical practice
and
thought about music relies on the other for substantial
parts of
its own perceived legitimacy. The only problem with this
'tit-for-tat' situation is that its negative interdependence
of
stances is based on a series of historical falsehoods.
In other
words, since conventional music studies in Europe and
North
America have in many ways painted a false image of this
continent's musical practices throughout the last few
centuries,
the negative print of that same image will be equally
inaccurate.
My talk will firstly attempt to identify some of these
historical
falsehoods in the form of widely held notions of polarity
between
the two spheres. 'High and low', 'cool and uncool' are
two popular
opposites, but some attention will be also paid to the
question of
media ('notation v. recording'), approach ('musicological
v.
sociological'), as well as to some 'commonsense' polarities
perceived in terms of 'mind v. body' and 'white v. black',
etc.
Having questioned the validity of these polarities, I
will discuss
the historical reasons for their construction and finish
by
suggesting other, hopefully less inaccurate, ways of
conceptualising differences between musical practices.
To
Top
Kirsten
Kearney
PhD student, University
of Stirling, UK
Playing Monopoly with the Academics
The academics wanted a monopoly
on it…they want it safe, so they draw a line
Van Morrison
This paper proposes to examine the effect of broadening the scope of ‘poetry’ to include lyrics drawn from different musical genres. It questions the notions of hierarchy within literature and argues for an acceptance of oral poetry as a valid and integral part of the literary canon. It deals with the concept of the crossover between poetry and song, examining the roots of the two genres and questioning the duality reflected in the two terms. It examines the notions of orality and the privileging of text over the spoken word, drawing on material by Havelock, Ong and the useful research of Ruth Finnegan.
As a focus for the paper, I have chosen the work of Van Morrison, a singer-songwriter from Northern Ireland whose work can be considered with poets such as Bob Dylan and Leonard Cohen who have been accepted by most literary establishments. The paper looks at the concept of popular music and how the approach of considering the popular song as literature affects our view of literature itself. The paper argues for the acceptance of Morrison as an aural poet and concerns itself with the interaction of word, music, sound and silence within his work.
It addresses the issues of the methods
involved in studying song as poetry and hopes to redress some of them.
To
Top
One more Grammy for Whitney
Houston:
annotations to musical roots
and musical identity in the era of globalization
Whitney Houston is one of the most
successful singers of popular music
worldwide. Already her first album
of 1985 went on to sell over 23
million copies; it became the biggest
selling debut and Rhythm & Blues
album by a female artist. Since
then Houston published three more
albums and three soundtracks ("Bodyguard",
among others) and amassed
countless awards (Grammy awards,
Billboard Awards, American Music
Awards, World Music Awards and
others). Till today Whitney Houston has
sold over 160 millions sound carriers.
In the course of the last Grammy
Awards Houston won a grammy in the
category "Female R&B Vocal
Performance" for her song "It´s Not Right
But It's Okay". This tune is an
exceptional example for a worldwide
recognizable kind of music that
seems to lack of an individual
musical language. A more exact
investigation shows, however, that
Houston is part of a musical tradition
that has its American origin in
the preachers of the black population.
On that base the present
lecture demonstrates the techniques
of Whitney Houston's vocal style
and compares them with the historic
forerunners. Especially the
changes in musical identity and
the musical consequences of the
globalization of popular music
are shown.
To
Top
The Depiction of Hope in Three Christian Popular Songs
During two millennia of polemics
concerning music's ability or
inability to convey or represent
emotion, the emotion of hope has often
been cited in connotation with both instrumental and texted music. This
study begins with arguments of
Mattheson, Hanslick and Meyer, and then
brings the more current debates
concerning affect in music to the field
of popular music analysis. It defines
hope as a thought, a thought
process, an emotion and a virtue,
and therewith, a broader notion that
most philosophers, theologians
and music theorists have usually assigned
it to be. Then, the paper
presents analyses of aspects of three songs
from Christian popular music, all
of which were made popular by the
"crossover" vocalist Amy Grant.
The texts of these songs deal with
different types of hopelessness
(frustration, despair and
disillusionment) which then proceed
to different objects of hope.
Moreover, the paper examines the
ways in which the text and form of the
songs differ progressively as Grant
successfully attempted to reach a
larger and more secular audience.
To
Top
Dr. Rosemary
Statelova
BAS - IAS, Dept.
of Ethnomusicology
Romany participation in the production of local popmusic in Bulgaria today: the ethomusicological approach
There “weren’t” Gypsies in Bulgaria
till 1990 at all: there were the so called “swarthy people”, who
lived in the “neighborhood” - the ghetto of the Roma. Now a
part of them do not live in the “neighborhood” any more. They are acting
vigorously on the new Bulgarian ethnopop music scene. This is one of the
very rare offers on behalf of the Bulgarian Roma to take part in the cultural
life of the society. The offer was accepted, thanks God. You can’t
study Gypsy music without studying the Gypsy musicians because “substantially”
there is not Gypsy music “as such”. The Gypsyness in the music is not a
question of “what” but of “how”. You can’t study Roma music without studying
its client, too: what matters here is the effort to make the client soft
and generous. So you have to go only one way: to try to make ethnomusicology
and anthropology of the recent Roma popmusic activity, that connects so
easily all Balkan ethnopop musics.
To
Top
Dr. Lubomir
Kavaldjiev
BAS - IAS, Information
Systems in Musical Culture
The Third Wave in Popular
Music
(four cognitive models observed
in the musical culture development)
Popular music emerged still at the
down of the civilizations and I relate to the term in its broadest sense.
As a subject of specialized scholar research it has been introduced only
after the mid-20th century. Drawing on the complementary categories of
the popular and the elite, I am trying to describe, explain, and prognosticate
the changes in the musical development from the perspectives of different,
competitive cognitive models. A starting point here is the A. Toffler’s
metaphor of the three civilization waves – a model I have related to in
my research work over the last three decades. I interpret this model in
its liberal and optimistic aspect, preferred by its author himself. In
addition, I introduce four cognitive models: three of them relate to the
development (DI, GIER, SDS) and one relating to the cultural functionality
(TIEM). I interpret them as complimentary in the whole field of contemporary
musical culture. Here these models are discussed briefly and in the context
of the status and the developments of popular music at the border between
20th and 21st centuries.
The extrapolation of all these
models leads to a common conclusion which I conceptualize in the hypothesis
according to which we are contemporaries of unseen in the last five centuries
fundamental transition in the musical and cultural development. The history
knows only two other shifts of similar significance: the emergence and
the spreading in Europe of the Christian civilization and the emergence
of the industrial (civic) society. From this point of view we can distinguish
today at least two types of co-existing popular musics: the one of the
nationally or regionally oriented industrial society and the one of the
global information society. The first type is popular among audiences having
attitudes to local, national, ethnic, and religious genre values, established
under the power of the tradition and the market. Usually it belongs to
the affirmative cultural practices and the establishment in the industrial
society. The second type is popular among the “population” of the Global
village and is understandable only in the context of the attitudes to the
globalization.
To
Top
Dr. Yetkin Ozer
Dokuz Eylul University,Turkey
Modern Sounds and Traditional
Images:
a video analysis and new
trends in Turkish folk music
The concept of communication in which the idea of message
occurring
between a sender and a receiver prevails has developed
a framework for
the study of music video, focusing on its impact on marketing
audio
production. This paper is to suggests that music video
is not only a
communicative means, but also a visual expression of
music that provides
musicians with another opportunity for performance. Thus,
the concept of
expression denotes here that thoughts and serntiments
are put in a kind of
medium regardless whether they are communicated. The
ways musicians
place themselves in their own video productions and the
roles they play in
the process of production may also be considered as behaviors
resulting
from their ideation and imagination related to their
own musics. The paper
is to base the analysis of a single music video on the
following remarks.
A survey of Turkish folk music videos in this respect
helps one distinguish
two opposing trends of performance:
1. Neo-traditionalism, fostered by musicians with experience
of
rural-to-urban migration, involving preservation of certain
features of
traditional folk music while recognizing changes in others.
In videos of
this
trend one can notice that video images are to illustrate
their orientation
towards tradition.
2. Deauthentification, exercised by native urban musicians
who perform
folk songs in a manner in which authenticity is not concerned.
The trend
finds its expression in videos with images and settings
mainly used by pop
singers of western orientation. Note that music video
in both groups serves
to visualize discourse on performance, but, on the other
hand, allow
individual musicians to develop their own strategies
in the process of
production.
Based on this framework the paper focuses on a musician
from the first
group, examining his behaviors during the production
of his first video
with reference to the concepts of modern and tradition.
It demonstrates the
interplay between his musical and visual renderings on
a traditional folk
song.
To
Top
Mercury Models:
Distortion of Language and
Identity in New Heavy Metal
In my paper I will demonstrate that contemporary heavy
metal rock groups
are displaying and giving voice to postmodern qualities
which are similar
to those described in critical works such as Jean Baudrillard's
"Simulacra
and Simulation". The ubiquitous presence of today's communications
media
has caused popular culture to be permeated and defined
by
simulacra-reproductions of reproductions-and I will use
the music of heavy
metal groups Korn and Deftones to show that new heavy
metal points to the
paradoxes inherent in the condition of postmodernity.
Among the several
facets of this music which demonstrate the pervasiveness
of the postmodern
phenomena identified by critics such as Baudrillard,
I will focus on the
disintegration of language and identity. The abstract/incoherent
lyrics and
the intense repetition present in the music of Deftones
and the non-lingual
utterances present in the music of Korn are manifestations
of the vocalists
coping with a perceived drainage of meaning in their
language. The semantic
coding of the lyrics/words has lost meaning due to the
accelerated
circulation of words, images, and information in North
American
hyper-capitalist, advertising/sign exchange, and my paper
will address the
heightened emotional and corporeal texture of their vocal
utterance which
reinserts meaning and indentity.
To
Top
Dr. Ulrich Dieter Einbrodt
Justus-Liebig-Universitaet
Giessen
Institut fuer Musikwissenschaften, Giessen
The Internet Musician. From
Trackers, Sequencers, Software-Synthesizers,
Virtual Sessions and MP3
Files: Changes in music production and distribution
Earlier (10 or more years ago), musicians who wanted to
make recordings of
their music had to invest in instruments and in expensive
technology such as
tape recorders, mixing consoles and effect devices. Nowadays
a personal
computer with internet connexion offers exciting – and
cheaper –
possibilities.
The Internet contains innumerable
addresses that have free or shareware
programs for download. Ranging from recording programs
to trackers and
synthesizers for interactive music-making, musicians
can work with these
programs and produce their own ideas. Moreover, the internet
provides the
new mp3-format for audio-files which is about to revolutionize
the
production and distribution market.
So how does the typical internet musician
work? He might start with
searching the software he needs. If he is a techno-freak,
he will look for
trackers, if he wants to record his guitar or voice,
he will look for
recording applications. Sequencers and software-synthesizers
are useful for
musicians of all styles, same as audio-editing tools.
Some of the shareware
programs are limited, so they can be used for about 30
days or some
functions will work only in the registered (and paid)
full version, but that
does not change their usefulness.
Having downloaded his programs, the
internet musician sets to work
creating recordings or files. In case of tracking files,
or sound files for
drum machines or synthesizers, he can exchange his files
with those from
others musicians on the net to get further inspiration.
When the internet musician has completed
his work, he can publish it
worlwide in the net, using an mp3 audio file. No question
he can offer
additional works that have to be paid for, using the
free mp3 files as
appetizers.
To
Top
Recordings of Hebrew Folk Songs in Israel
The so-called Hebrew folk song repertoire
in Israel consists largely of
songs by known composers. It was
established well before the foundation of
the state of Israel and continued
to flourish after 1948. Only some of the
repertoire had already received
commercial performances when it was new,
and little has survived through
contemporary recordings. Most recordings of
the repertoire date from 1970s
and 1980s; their release coincided with the
spread of pop and rock in Israel.
An examination of the corpus of
recordings reveals an acute consciousness
of the gap between old and new.
This awareness is manifested in various
ways, ranging from ironic quotations
to attempts to resuscitate older
performance practices. Between
these extremes, many recordings update the
atmosphere of old songs in order
to make them more accessible to
contemporary audiences e.g. by
making instrumentation, rhythm and harmony
more Western.
Other driving forces behind the
creation of new recordings include the need
to preserve neglected songs (e.g.
of pioneers' songs), legitimization of
popular culture (e.g. "street songs"),
commercial potential (since the
repertoire is perceived as being
culturally highbrow), and orders from
state media.
Recordings of this repertoire remained
abundant until the early 1990s, but
have gradually diminished in recent
years. The basic trends in the corpus
remained constant throughout the
last generation. The body of work has
strong parallels in cover versions
of Western classics, but nevertheless
exhibits a strong local flavor.
To
Top
Cross-Border Flow of Popular
Culture: Redefining Cultural
Boundaries and Traditions
in Bulgaria and Turkey
Aiming at integration with the world
economy compels developing
countries like Bulgaria and Turkey
to rely on reinterpreting and
reconstructing meanings of "imported"
cultural artifacts, traditions
and symbols to cultivate national
identity, and redefine cultural
boundaries. One example of this
is the diffusion of American and
British influenced popular music
into Turkey after World-War II.
Previous popular music in Turkey
evolved from three nineteenth century
traditions: 1.) urban popular music
influenced by Turkish folk songs
known as "turku," 2.) a synthetically
stylized, commercial type of light
music called "piyasa musikisi,"
and 3.) entertainment music consisting
solely of popular songs (sharki)
and dance tunes (oyun havasi, kocekce).
Modernized international traditions,
on the other hand, incorporate a wide
variety of electronically-produced
styles and genres produced and
distributed by the American and
British recording industry, including
blues, folk, rock and roll, and
punk, which have become transplanted into
Turkey.
This paper
examines the impact of the dissemination of popular music
transmitted into the country by
the international recording industry. The
data for this paper was compiled
in Istanbul and other Turkish cities in
1995 and 1996. Findings from my
own, as well as previous reseach bu others
indicate that social acceptance
of innovative popular music diffused into
Turkey was initiated by youth subcultures
on the basis of symbolic meaning
constituted through the mass media.
My most recent research has led to the
conclusion that the diffusion underwent
four stages of development:
1.) consumption in the fifties,
2.) imitation in the sixties and early
seventies, 3.) deanglicization
in the seventies, and 4.) reethnification
in the eighties and nineties.
To
Top
Playing on Repetitive:
Creativity in Popular Music/Culture
Though already acknowledged in modern humanities as ‘music
that matters’, contemporary popular music is often studied mostly on the
ground of its extra-musical rather than on its intra-musical qualities.
Usually, such a neglecting is a result of the still prevailing attitude
among scholars (especially in musicology) who - even ready to appreciate
popular music’s social significance - note the inferiority of the ‘music
itself’ and re-produce in fact a mis/wrong-understanding of the specific
logic, tools, priorities, meanings and values, articulated in popular music
practices. This paper aims to identify a concept, hopefully applicable
in distinguishing and understanding popular music ‘as both music and culture’,
which I name metaphorically playing on repetitive. Employing the
concept of the ‘changing same’ (Gilroy 1993), I am going further to outline
specific, priority aesthetic attitudes shifting the ideas of artistic complexity
and creativity in major 20th century music practices which favor - in general
and in one by no means historically accelerated way - the repetition. In
addition to the obvious impact of African and African-American derived
practices giving priority to the category of repetition, I consider as
well the parallel fuel for such aesthetic shifts coming both from other
‘marginal’, traditional or ethnic music practices and from innovative technological
flow, bringing, after all, an Alternative to Modernity, rooted in the ‘great
individuality’ associated with the European Enlightenment. This alternative
stimulate folk-like cultural forms, that is the repetitive rather than
the shocking innovation, the playing rather than the fixed opus, the conventional
rather than the autonomous, the circular rather than the linear, the dialogical
rather than the monological, the shared performing and participation rather
than the alienated music making, the intertextuality rather than the single
textuality, the passing temporality rather than the idea of eternal universality,
etc. While being aware of the limitations of one only concept in
distinguishing the peculiarities in the variety of popular music styles,
the discussion on the playing on repetitive would give possible
insights into basic artistic approaches shaping the specific creativity
observed in dominant styles including jazz, blues, country, rock, rap,
world music, or techno, and their pop offsprings.
To
Top
'America's Band [again]':
the mid-seventies Beach Boys
and pop music as repositioning
Since its modernist inception, popular music commentary
has concerned
itself with aspects of reception (Adorno's "Theory about
the listener,"
a clear contradiction in terms) and of repetition (Richard
Middleton's
work, for example). Even if neither of these categories
has found its
definite presence and application in the form of a basal
terminology for
the discipline, their intersection forms that combination
of the
phenomenological and the structural that is indispensable
in any
analysis. Trying to keep this juxtaposition close to
my concerns,
therefore, I investigate in this paper the abiding significance
for a
consideration of the globalization of American music
of the rebirth of
the Beach Boys in themid-seventies, a time when they
first began to be known
as "America's band", a label which, as I hope to
show, may be seen ironically,
given the international outreach and positioning of the
band at this time, the
relative inactivity then of pivotal member Brian Wilson,
and the band's
choice of repertoire in general and musical structures
in particular.
Songs discussed will include "Sail On, Sailor" (from
Holland, 1973), and
"It's O.K." (from 15 Big Ones, 1976), as well as two
Brian Wilson songs
unreleased at the time "It's Over Now" and "Still I Dream
of It." Along
the way, I hope to tackle certain abiding preconceptions
about the
packaging of the band and of the period's American popular
music, and to
perhaps replace them with others.
To
Top
General info | Administration | Departments | Libraries | Journals | Folklore Database | Links |